Usually whenever dates are supplied, he or she is given which have 1 day of your own week one to does not match with that go out as it when you look at the actual history. One example happens in Harry Potter as well as the Prisoner from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney makes reference to sixteen October because Tuesday, even in the event 16 Oct 1993 was a friday.
There are also contradictions in the instructions in this region. Such, in Harry Potter and also the Cup from Flames, each other 1 September and dos September are offered given that Mondays and you can, in Harry Potter and Prisoner regarding Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is decided to your 20 April, however, cautious parsing of one’s text message shows that this may features occurred no after than just February.
Along with, in the Harry Potter as well as the Cup regarding Fire people say the Winners was in fact selected for the Saturday 31 Oct, but 30 Oct are a monday inside the 1994.
When you look at the chapter 7 from Quidditch From Many years, people say that the basic Quidditch Globe Cup was held inside 1473. Whether your title are held every number of years, which problems to the statement in Goblet from Fire that the 1994 World Mug is the fresh 422nd. If the Quidditch From the Years is great, the fresh 422nd Quidditch World Glass create indeed fall in the entire year 3161, however, if Cup of Flames is great, the original World Glass ended up being kept in the 306.
Historic problems [ ]
Even though the series, depending on the schedule based on the new Chamber out of Treasures resource, is decided about nineties, the series often seems as though it’s place in the later nineties so you’re able to middle-2000s, around concurrent on guide of your courses. When you look at the Harry Potter plus the Half of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to refer towards the “predecessor” of one’s Prime Minister of your own Uk. With regards to the above timeline, this will take place in summer time out of 1996, if Finest Minister is John Significant, whose instant predecessor try a woman (‘s first ending up in Fudge, the book mentions the brand new election, however, Big was not very first opted and just took more immediately following Thatcher retired.
You’ll be able, however unrealistic, one to Fudge might be talking about a very distant predecessor, since the Thatcher took work environment just before Fudge allegedly became Minister to possess Wonders. (Even if you can think a situation in which Fudge is delegated because of the Minister to possess Wonders to get to know on Primary Minister as he, Fudge, was at a smaller workplace.) In addition, new identity and you will reputation of the prime Minister represented seems to so much more closely matches that of Tony Blair than simply regarding John Biggest. An article regarding Every single day Mail cards one Rowling try personal into after that-Chancellor of your Exchequer Gordon Brownish (usually regarded as an opponent to help you Blair’s management of your Labor Group, whom succeeded your and you can turned Finest Minister), hence she has been attempting to inform you Blair’s bad front. If your instructions was place in connect with publication go out out-of Philosopher’s Brick, up coming which event create occur in 2002 (just after Blair became Best Minister).
But not, it was after stated that 22 November is actually a tuesday, it was a student in 1994
A comparable disease pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was said as actually 665 at the time of the new earliest publication, but Nicolas Flamel are a bona-fide historic shape and you can wouldn’t have reached you to definitely years up until 1996, around the go out the initial guide is actually authored. The newest rebuttal for this is that the date the fresh new “real” Nicolas Flamel was born doesn’t keep in touch with the latest Nicolas Flamel out of Harry Potter.
A different state is present regarding Rubeus Hagrid’s tenure since Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is designed about series one to Hagrid obtained one to reputation contained in this a few years of his expulsion out of college or university inside the 1942. But in you to world regarding Harry Potter therefore the Cup of Flame, Molly Weasley reminisces regarding Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently convergence with Molly’s age in school, it looks impractical you to definitely she recalls a previous gamekeeper. However, you’ll be able that Hagrid don’t getting good gamekeeper quickly just after being expelled, but instead started as the Ogg’s assistant. This is possible once the when Harry thinks that he commonly feel expelled for traveling into the broomstick versus permission inside bride Aracaju the first 12 months, the guy secret in the event that he would be allowed to stick to just like the Hagrid’s assistant.
